Your local changes to the following files would be overwritten by merge как исправить

Here is my strategy to solve the problem.

Problem Statement

We need to make changes in more than 10 files. We tried PULL (git pull origin master), but Git shouted:

error: Your local changes to the following files would be overwritten
by merge: Please, commit your changes or stash them before you can
merge.

We tried to execute commit and then pull, but they didn’t work either.

Solution

We were in the dirty stage actually, because the files were in the «Staging Area» a.k.a «Index Area» and some were in the «Head Area» a.k.a «local Git directory». And we wanted to pull the changes from the server.

Check this link for information about different stages of Git in a clear manner: GIT Stages

We followed the following steps

  • git stash (this made our working directory clean. Your changes are stored on the stack by Git).
  • git pull origin master (Pull the changes from the server)
  • git stash apply (Applied all the changes from stack)
  • git commit -m 'message' (Committed the changes)
  • git push origin master (Pushed the changes to the server)
  • git stash drop (Drop the stack)

Let’s understand when and why you need stashing

If you are in the dirty state, means you are making changes in your files and then you are compelled, due to any reason, to pull or switch to another branch for some very urgent work, so at this point you can’t pull or switch until you commit your change. The stash command is here as a helping hand.

From the book ProGIT, 2nd Edition:

Often, when you’ve been working on part of your project, things are in
a messy state and you want to switch branches for a bit to work on
something else. The problem is, you don’t want to do a commit of
half-done work just so you can get back to this point later. The
answer to this issue is the git stash command. Stashing takes the
dirty state of your working directory – that is, your modified tracked
files and staged changes – and saves it on a stack of unfinished
changes that you can reapply at any time.

  • honor8

Как правильно сделать слияние чужих и своих изменений?

работаем вдвоем над одним проектом, я поработал и хочу закоммитить изменения в репозиторий, перед этим делаю git pull и получаю

error: Your local changes to the following files would be overwritten by merge:
	1.php
	2.php
       3.php
Please, commit your changes or stash them before you can merge.
Aborting

т. е  в этим файлах у меня свои наработки,  и второй прогер уже закинул в репозиторий свои изменения,  вопрос.
Как мне его изменения слить и так чтобы не потерять свои изменения?  Вообщем как мне правильно все сделать и закоммитить


  • Вопрос задан

    более трёх лет назад

  • 15446 просмотров

Пригласить эксперта

Please, commit your changes or stash them before you can merge.

Что в этой фразе не понятного?

Вариант 1. — Делаете коммит, а котом git pull и оно вам предложит смержить.
Вариант 2. — Делаете git stash (прячет все незакомиченые локальные изменения); затем git pull; затем git stash pop, а дальше мержите.

Вообще есть третий вариант (на будущее) — создаете локально еще одну ветку, в ней работаете, а потом делаете git pull в основной ветке (точнее в той, от которой вы отпочковались) и мержите с ней свою ветку. (опять же, можете сделать stash, затем «отпочковаться», затем слить изменения с репозитория и потом stash pop в свою ветку, а затем мержитесь, когда надо, с той веткой, откуда отпочковались).

Тут у вас есть несколько проблем:
1. команда git pull это на самом деле алиас для git fetch + git merge
работает она так, сначала через git fetch получает новое состояние ветки из origin, а потом передает управление git merge, он в свою очередь если ваша ветка разошлась делает merge, если нет то делает fast forward как следствие могут появиться не нужные комиты вида "Merge branch "test" to "test""

По этому советую вместо git pull делать всегда git fetch, а потом смотреть git status а там уже либо git rebase origin/test либо git pull

2. так же как вам уже сказали выше у вас есть изменения в локальных файлах, в целом в этом нет ничего плохого, их можно либо спрятать через git stash либо сделать комит

хочу закоммитить изменения в репозиторий, перед этим делаю git pull

Вот не надо ничего делать, пока не закоммитил. Git просто таки предназначен, чтобы коммитить часто. Закоммитил — считай, сохранил навсегда, и уже не потеряешь

Вести совместную разработку в одной ветви — плохой тон.

  1. *git pull --rebase --autostash создаётся ветвь refs/stash.
  2. git status могут появиться файлы modified (changed & indexed) и both modified (conflicted).
  3. git stash drop отбросить ветвь refs/stash. Затем заняться конфликтами.


  • Показать ещё
    Загружается…

29 мая 2023, в 11:20

35000 руб./за проект

29 мая 2023, в 11:18

100 руб./за проект

29 мая 2023, в 11:09

30000 руб./за проект

Минуточку внимания

The error message “Your local changes to the following files will be overwritten by merge” occurs in Git version control mechanism. This error occurs if you have modified a file which also has modifications in the remote repository.

Git Error ‘Your local changes to the following files will be overwritten by merge’

Git Error ‘Your local changes to the following files will be overwritten by merge’ Fix

This error message is avoided IF there are no uncommitted files that also have modifications in the remote repository. When experiencing this message, it is best to consult your other team members and ask for their opinion. Whether you want to merge your local changes or keep the version present in the repository, it is best to keep everyone on board.

What are repositories? What are push and pull in Git?

A repository is a kind of storage for code which is constantly modified and obtained by team members through the GitHub version control mechanism. A ‘Pull’ means that you are pulling the latest version of the repository onto your local storage/IDE (Integrated Development Environment) such as Pycharm etc.

After a Pull, you make changes to the code or add more features. Once you are done, you ‘Push’ the code onto the repository so changes are saved and additions are made. The code gets accessible to other people as well.

If you are new to Github version control, it is recommended that you go through all the basics first. In this article, we assume that you already have basic knowledge and know all the ins and outs.

How to fix ‘Your local changes to the following files will be overwritten by merge’?

The resolution of this error message depends on what you want to do. You can discard your local changes and pull the ones in the repository or you can save your local changes into a stash and pull the version from the repository. It all depends on your preference.

Hence, we recommend that you consult with your team members and make sure that you all are on the same page before moving forward. If you commit wrongly or push the wrong version, it could affect the entire team.

Method 1: Forcing a pull to overwrite local changes

If you don’t care about the changes done locally and want to obtain the code from the repository, you can force a pull. This will overwrite all the local changes done on your computer a duplicate copy of the version in the repository will appear.

Execute the following commands in your IDE:

git reset -- hard

git pull

This will instantly destroy all your local changes so make sure that you know what you are doing and don’t need your local changes.

Method 2: Keeping both changes (local and from the repo)

If you want to keep both changes (changes done locally and changes present in the repository), you can add and commit your changes. When you pull, there will obviously be a merge conflict. Here you can use the tools in your IDE (such as Difftool and mergetool) to compare the two pieces of code and determine which changes to keep and which to remove. This is the middle way; no changes will be lost until you manually remove them.

git add $the_file_under_error

git commit

git pull

When you get a merge conflict, pop those conflict resolving tools and check line by line.

Method 3: Keeping both changes BUT not committing

This situation happens from time to time where developers are not ready to commit because there is some partly broken code which you are debugging. Here we can stash the changes safely, pull the version from the repository, and then unstash your code.

git stash save --keep-index

or

git stash
git pull

git stash pop

If there are some conflicts after you pop the stash, you should resolve them in the usual way. You can also use the command:

git stash apply

instead of pop if you are not ready to lose the stashed code due to conflicts.

If merge doesn’t seem like a viable option for you, consider doing a rebase. Rebasing is the process of moving or combining a sequence of commits to a new base commit. In the case of rebasing, change the code to:

git stash

git pull --rebase origin master

git stash pop

Method 4: Make changes to ‘specific’ parts of your code

If you want to make changes to specific parts of the code and don’t want to replace everything, you can commit everything that you don’t want to overwrite and then follow method 3. You can use the following command for the changes which you want to overwrite from the version present in the repository:

git checkout path/to/file/to/revert

or

git checkout HEAD^ path/to/file/to/revert

Also, you need to make sure that the file is not staged via:

git reset HEAD path/to/file/to/revert

Then proceed with the pull command:

git pull

This will then attempt at fetching the version from the repository.

Photo of Kevin Arrows

Kevin Arrows

Kevin Arrows is a highly experienced and knowledgeable technology specialist with over a decade of industry experience. He holds a Microsoft Certified Technology Specialist (MCTS) certification and has a deep passion for staying up-to-date on the latest tech developments. Kevin has written extensively on a wide range of tech-related topics, showcasing his expertise and knowledge in areas such as software development, cybersecurity, and cloud computing. His contributions to the tech field have been widely recognized and respected by his peers, and he is highly regarded for his ability to explain complex technical concepts in a clear and concise manner.

  • MiniTool

  • MiniTool News Center

  • Fix Git Error — Your Local Changes Would Be Overwritten by Merge

By Daisy | Follow |
Last Updated August 31, 2022

google search

If you have modified files that also have modifications in the remote repository, you may receive the “your local changes to the following files would be overwritten by merge” error message. This post from MiniTool offers fixes.

What Is a Repository? What Is Push and Pull in Git?

What is a repository? A repository is a store of code that team members are constantly modifying and fetching through the GitHub version control mechanism.

«Pull» means that you pull the latest version of the repository to your local storage/IDE (Integrated Development Environment) such as Pycharm etc. After pulling, you can change the code or add more functionality. When you’re done, you «push» your code to the repository so your changes can be saved and added. Others can also access the code.

How to Fix “Your Local Changes to the Following Files Would Be Overwritten by Merge”

Fix 1: Force a Pull to Overwrite Local Changes

The first method for you is to force a pull to overwrite local changes. This will overwrite any local changes done on your computer and a copy of the version in the repository will appear. You need to run the following commands in IDE.

  • git reset — hard
  • git pull

Then, you can check if the “error: your local changes to the following files would be overwritten by merge:” message has gone.

Fix 2: Keep Both Changes

If you want to keep both of these changes (the one done locally and the one in the repository), you can add and commit your changes. You need to execute the following codes in IDE:

  • git add $the_file_under_error
  • git commit
  • git pull

Fix 3: Keep Both Changes but Not Commit

It happens from time to time that the developer is not ready to commit because you are debugging some partially broken code. Here we can safely stash the changes, pull the version from the repository, and unstore your code.

  • git stash save —keep-index

or

  • git stash
  • git pull
  • git stash pop

If there are some conflicts after popping into the store, you should resolve them in the usual way. You can also use the following codes:

  • git stash apply

If merging is not a viable option for you, consider rebasing In the case of rebasing, change the code to

  • git stash
  • git pull —rebase origin master
  • git stash pop

Fix 4: Make Changes to Parts of Your Code

If you want to make changes to a specific part of the code and don’t want to replace everything, you can commit everything you don’t want to override and follow fix 3. You can use the following codes to make changes you want to override from the version that exists in the repository:

  • git checkout path/to/file/to/revert

or

  • git checkout HEAD^ path/to/file/to/revert

Also, you need to make sure that the file is not staged via:

  • git reset HEAD path/to/file/to/revert
  • git pull

Also see: Fix Git Error: You Need to Resolve Your Current Index First Now!

Final Words

These are common solutions to fix “your local changes would be overwritten by merge” in Git. If you have any other useful methods to remove this error, leave a comment below to let us know.

About The Author

Daisy

Position: Columnist

Daisy graduated with a major in English and then joined MiniTool as an editor. She specializes in writing articles about backing up data & systems, cloning disks, and syncing files, etc. She is also good at writing articles about computer knowledge and computer issues. In daily life, she likes running and going to the amusement park with friends to play some exciting items.

When working on a project with a team, you might stumble upon error messages like these when trying to perform a «git pull» in your repository:

error: Your local changes to the following files would be overwritten by merge: ...

-or-

error: Untracked working tree file 'images/icon.png' would be overwritten by merge

The reason for error messages like these is rather simple: you have local changes that would be overwritten by the incoming new changes that a «git pull» would bring in.

For obvious safety reasons, Git will never simply overwrite your changes. This also means that there is no «force pull» feature in Git — but we can of course perform a couple of steps to emulate such a command.

Step 1: Cleaning Up the Working Copy

First, you’ll need to make sure your working copy doesn’t contain these conflicting changes anymore. There are two ways to achieve this:

a) Saving Local Changes on a Stash

If you want to preserve your local changes, you can safely store them on a Stash. They will be available in case you want them back at a later point.

$ git stash --include-untracked

b) Discarding Local Changes

If you are sure that you don’t need them anymore, you can discard your local changes completely:

$ git reset --hard

If you also have untracked / new files, you will have to use the «git clean» command to get rid of these, too:

$ git clean -fd

Please be careful with these commands: discarding local changes and untracked files cannot be undone!

Step 2: Pull Again

After you have cleaned up any local changes / untracked files that would have been overwritten, the pull will finally work:

$ git pull

Auto-Stashing in Tower

If you’re using the Tower Git client, you’ll notice that it helps you avoid these situations: whenever you have uncommitted local changes present and want to perform an action like Pull, Checkout or Merge, Tower will automatically offer to store these changes safely on a Stash.

This way, you neither have to take any extra steps nor do you have to think about this anymore.

Learn More

  • Check out the chapter Integrating Remote Changes in our free online book
  • More frequently asked questions about Git & version control

Понравилась статья? Поделить с друзьями:

Не пропустите также:

  • Как найти площадь революции
  • Как в 1с найти остатки на складах
  • Как найти пенсионерки подругу
  • Найти как уговорить девушку на секс
  • Как найти мужа имея двух детей

  • 0 0 голоса
    Рейтинг статьи
    Подписаться
    Уведомить о
    guest

    0 комментариев
    Старые
    Новые Популярные
    Межтекстовые Отзывы
    Посмотреть все комментарии